Set Lyrics Loop
For words that already exist (a hymn, a poem, your own writing): keep every word, and build the record around it.
Anyone setting existing words to music: a public-domain hymn or poem, scripture, or lyrics the person wrote. The words are fixed; the style lives in the arrangement and in whatever additions the setting allows.
This is the opposite discipline from writing new lyrics. The source text is a fixed spine: every word stays, in order, at its original syllable count. The creativity goes into the arrangement, the cues and the additions the setting allows.
One setting decides how much may be added. None: the exact text only; repeating a whole source line is allowed, but no new words, ad-libs or vocables. Limited: a faithful chorus, intro, outro, bridge or in-between part grown from the text's own lines, images and meaning. Open: more new material around the text, such as a new verse or a rap section.
The setting comes from the plan, else the project, else the person's preference. If nothing says, ask; if you can't ask, use none. A project's setting is a ceiling: a plan may narrow it, never widen it.
Every setting keeps the same floor: the source is pinned to an exact edition or revision, every original word stays in order, every addition is labelled, rights are checked before anything is generated, and the source words are never rewritten, not to sing better and not to get past a generator's filter.
Hymns are the most common case and have their own section (the Using-Text Hymn Loop is this loop's hymn preset). Writing spends nothing; this loop stops at a checked sheet unless the person has said to generate.
Skills & actions it uses
The concrete, reusable skills this loop calls to actually do the work.
The Hymn LibraryExact hymn text, its revision and its rights evidence. Read it; never edit it.music_context / music_readRead the additions setting, the project's rules and the plan before arranging.music_saveSave the sheet, style prompt, setting used, rights basis and check report on the plan; log each generation attempt separately.
The loop
- 1
Pin the source
Get the exact text, its edition or revision, and who wrote it. For a hymn, the Hymn Library text and revision; for a poem or the person's own writing, the text they saved or gave you.
- Keep the text as published, including old spellings and contractions
- Note the stanza and refrain structure
- Record where it came from so anyone can check it
- 2
Check the rights
The text must be public domain with evidence (a date and a citation), the person's own work, or used with permission. If it doesn't clear, stop and offer a new song based on it with the Jarvie Music Writing Loop.
- Unknown is not clear: research it first, or write based-on
- Record the rights basis on the plan before anything is generated
- 3
Read the setting and the hard rules
Find the additions setting (none, limited or open) on the plan, else the project, else the person's preference. Ask if nothing says; use none if you can't ask.
- A plan may narrow the project's setting, never widen it
- Note the project's avoid list and any scoped rules, such as a calm album; they are never traded for an arrangement idea
- 4
Lock the spine
Every stanza, refrain and word, in order, at the original syllable count.
- Capitalisation, punctuation and line breaks may be normalised; nothing else
- Keep old spellings and contractions (o'er, e'en, 'tis, heav'n): they hold the meter. Expanding o'er to over adds a syllable and rewrites the line
- If the generator mis-sings one, respell it at the same syllable count (o'er → ore), never expand it
- A phonetic respelling of a hard name is a pronunciation aid, not a text change. List each one for the check
- Note which whole lines may repeat. Repeating a line is allowed; changing it is not
- 5
Read for meaning, meter and the line that wants repeating
A short read, not a study: the central image and feeling to carry, where the text breathes, and the line strong enough to be the hook.
- 6
Choose the style and voice
Follow the Style and voice section: the sub-genre the plan or project names, or three options if it is open, voiced as a blend of two or three study artists from its centre.
- 7
Arrange it the way an artist of that style would
With fixed words, this is where the style lives: the section map, where the hook sits, bar counts, repeats, breaks and call-and-response. See Arranging around fixed words.
- 8
Write the additions the setting allows
Write only what the setting permits, and label every addition as an addition.
- None: nothing new. Repeats of whole lines and instrumental sections only
- Limited: lift the hook from a whole existing line where you can (one continuous run, nothing inserted or dropped); every other addition grows from the text's own lines, images and meaning
- Open: new verses or a rap section are allowed, but the source still appears complete and in order
- 9
Write the sheet and the style prompt
Write the sheet in the Lyric sheet format and the prompt with the Style prompt and cues method, which matters most when the words are fixed. Keep a note with the sheet that marks which sung lines are original and which are additions.
- 10
Check before handoff
Run a pass/fail check. A fail is fixed, never shipped.
- Strip every cue, ad-lib, addition and repeat, undo the respellings and normalise case and punctuation: what remains is the source, word for word, in order
- Additions are within the setting, each labelled with the source line or image it draws from
- Report the share of sung lines that are additions
- Non-sung lines bracketed; ad-libs in parentheses; no artist name
- Rights recorded; the project's rules met
- Where a project turns on lyric preservation, the site also checks the saved sheet against the pinned hymn revision before generation can start
- 11
Save and hand off, and never bend the text
Save the sheet, style prompt, setting used, rights basis and check report on the plan, and say which AI model wrote it. Don't generate unless the person said to. If a generator refuses the lyric, follow When a generator refuses the text; never reword the source to get past a filter.
Then run it again for the next song, chapter, or track.
When it applies
Shared methods and special cases. Each one is used only when its situation applies.
Style and voiceEvery song, at the step where you choose the style.
- Use the sub-genre the plan, project or catalog names. If it is open, propose three distinct directions (sub-genre, era, texture, tempo, vocal mode), lock one, and say in one sentence why it fits.
- Start from the centre of that sub-genre: the sound its most influential artists, now and traditionally, would recognise as their own. The genre encyclopedia entry names them.
- Voice the song as a blend of two or three study artists from that centre, and say what each one brings: cadence, vocabulary, attitude, an arrangement habit.
- Artist names stay in your notes. They never appear in the lyric, the style prompt or the title.
- The project's direction outranks your taste: its avoid list, what to use sparingly, and its rules.
- Religious words do not choose the genre. Aim for normal-sounding music in the chosen style that happens to carry those words. Gospel is one style among many, never the default.
Lyric sheet formatWriting the sheet a generator will read.
- [Square brackets] hold everything that is not sung: section labels, performance cues and production direction, each on its own line.
- (Parentheses) hold only words or sounds that are sung: ad-libs, echoes, call-and-response. Never instructions.
- Everything else gets sung, so nothing else goes in the lyric box: no notes, no explanations, no artist names.
- Generators favour the words. An instrumental break, a solo or a no-vocal moment happens only if a bracket asks for it.
- Choose instruction density on purpose. Heavy: many cues, when the lyric is short or the style is far from the generator's habits. Light: a few anchors, when the lyric is long or the style is organic.
- Respell a hard name phonetically in the sung line at the same syllable count (Nephi → Nee-fye) and keep the real spelling in your notes. Never write both in the line; the generator may sing both.
Style prompt and cuesWriting the style prompt and placing cues in the sheet.
- Lead with the sub-genre, then three to five instruments, the vocal mode (sung, rapped, spoken or a mix), one emotional anchor and a rough length.
- Name techniques, not only a genre: the call-and-response, the half-time drop, the stacked harmonies, the hush before the last chorus. Put the most identifying one first.
- Place each technique as a bracket cue in the section where it fires, so the cues trace the song's energy instead of sitting everywhere.
- Every technique in the prompt has at least one matching cue in the sheet, and every cued technique fits the prompt. Together they carry the style far better than a genre label.
- Describe the voice in craft words. Never name an artist.
- Keep the prompt within the limit of the generator and model you are using. Limits change between models: check the generator's own screen rather than a number remembered from before, and don't repeat what the cues already say.
- When the words are fixed, this is where most of the style lives.
Arranging around fixed wordsLaying out the sections around a fixed text.
- Verses only: [Intro] · Verse 1 · Hook · Verse 2 · Hook · [Bridge] · Verse 3 · Hook · [Outro].
- With a refrain: [Intro] · Verse 1 · Refrain · Verse 2 · Refrain · [Bridge] · Verse 3 · Refrain, fullest · [Outro].
- Make it longer with repeats of whole lines and instrumental sections, never with new verses. Three verses in, three verses out.
- The bridge is the risky place: keep it instrumental, or repeat a whole source line, unless the setting allows new words.
- Dynamics cues do the most work: strip to voice and piano, build, drop to drums only, full band.
- Where the setting allows ad-libs, the safest are non-lexical sounds (ooh, oh, mm) or an echo of words in that same line. A word the text never says is an addition: it must be allowed and labelled.
When a generator refuses the textA generator's filter refuses a lyric whose rights you have confirmed.
- Confirm the rights again first. A refusal on unconfirmed text is a reason to stop, not to try harder.
- Attempt 1: the exact text with everything the setting allows: cues, structure, permitted additions and the real title.
- Attempt 2: change what surrounds the words, not the words. Adjust the title (add "(Hymn Setting)", use a phrase from the text, or use the first line), add instrumental sections and more production cues between lines, and, under limited or open, more of the permitted additions.
- Stop there. No attempt changes, swaps, reorders or drops a source word, not even one or two of the most-matchable phrases. Same-syllable respellings are pronunciation aids, not a way past a filter.
- Save each attempt as its own prompt and generation attempt on the plan, with the generator's exact message.
- After the last attempt, park the plan and offer a based-on song with the Jarvie Music Writing Loop, linked to the parked plan. Trying another generator is the person's call.
When the source is a hymnThe text is a hymn (this is the Using-Text Hymn preset).
- Use the Hymn Library's exact text and its revision. The library holds the text as published; don't expand its contractions.
- The rights must be supported public domain: a publication or author date and a citation. If the library marks the text as not public domain or unknown, offer a based-on song instead.
- The verses and any original refrain are fixed. A refrain is the chorus. With no refrain, lift a whole line as the hook: first a line that already recurs, then the title or thesis line.
- Alternate tunes that share a text count as one text. The words are fixed, not the tune.
- Make it sound like a normal record in the chosen style that happens to carry these words. Left alone, generators drift to organ, choir and a slow hymn tempo, so cue the style clearly. Gospel is one style among many, never the default.
- The additions setting is the project's choice. This preset assumes limited; a project or plan that says none wins.
- If the project marks some hymns or an album as calm or reverent, that rule outranks energy.
You end with
- A pinned source with its rights basis recorded
- A lyric sheet that keeps every source word in order, with cues and only the additions the setting allows, each labelled
- A style prompt whose techniques match the cues in the sheet
- A pass/fail check report: source intact, additions listed with their share, rules met
- If a generator refused: each attempt logged, and a based-on fallback offered rather than changed words
Skip this loop if…
- You want to change the words so they sing better: that is a new song based on the text, so use the Jarvie Music Writing Loop
- The rights are unknown and can't be confirmed: research them first, or write based-on
How it connects
Pairs with
Commonly run just before or after this one in the pipeline.
Write new lyrics from a seed: study it, brainstorm wide, converge on one hook, then write a performance-ready sheet and style prompt.
Research a hymn and store its public-domain lyrics + reusable research in the library — once, for every project.
The Suno-native loop: a writing loop produces the words, then you format, prompt, and submit a finished song into Suno.